« Fuelcasting
Main
PayEnemy »
How could you POSSIBLY?

I'm usually the first to understand that sometimes there's functionality that's so juicy that you'll put up with some pain to get it. But the trouble with Flickr is that when you choose to use it, you're not just experiencing its awful horrors yourself, but you're inflicting horror on everyone who you hope to have as your photo audience.

There is so much that I despise about Flickr's user interface that it's difficult to even BEGIN to describe how it makes my blood boil. How could you people possibly tolerate using it?

I mean, just for one of like a hundred examples, look at the insane little photo nav widget they have. (One of 6 or so different ways to navigate photos, by the way. Do you need 6 ways? Do you?) The widget shows you 1) some photo that seems irrelevant, 2) some other photo that seems irrelevant, 3) the total number of photos in some kind of group that you appear to be lost in, and then 4) gives you the choice to see "more"? Or instead of "more" would you like "more"? And if you click on the photo, you seem to just be lost again.

Yes yes, I understand that it's paging through the photos. But why does it refuse to tell you where you are? And refuse to show you where the photo you're looking at is? Even though I know exactly how to use it, and I understand what it's doing, it still makes me angry every time I have to see it. Every time.

I realize that there's not a lot of choice of other services. Certainly Picasa Web Albums isn't really designed to store your original photos the way Flickr is, but I'm sure someone over there is working on that. And then you will stop using Flickr. You WILL. I COMMAND YOU!

Comments

Amen, brother. I couldn't agree with you more.

I've been decrying their user interface for as long as they've been butchering it, which is for as long as I can remember.

I'm sure Jackson Pollock is turning in his grave knowing that someone stole his "let's throw a bunch of shit at a white canvas" method and applied it to user interfaces.

Posted by: Reuben at March 15, 2007 09:32 AM

Reuben was telling me yesterday how much he hates the Flickr interface. The funny thing is I have always found it easy to use. Perhaps it is just that it was a photo sharing solution that didn't force me to always create an album for everything. Hard to say. Could be you are just too smart for the interface. Works for us Product Managers.

Posted by: Scott Johnston at March 15, 2007 03:00 PM

See that's exactly my point. The album management interface might be awesome. It might give you a blow job. Who knows. But browsing the albums you create using the *browsing* interface makes me want to poison the skies.

Posted by: Rus at March 15, 2007 03:36 PM

But... I like Flickr! I've been a paid user for about three years now, I've never had a problem with it.

Posted by: Seth at March 19, 2007 01:58 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?






The views expressed on this site are mine personally, and do not necessarily reflect the views of my employer.